Another Stumble for Reeling CNN  | American Journalism Review
 AJR  Features
From AJR,   June/July 2012

Another Stumble for Reeling CNN   

Its ratings sinking, the cable news pioneer makes a high-profile mistake on the Supreme Courts health care ruling. Thurs., June 28, 2012.

By Rem Rieder
Rem Rieder ( is AJR's editor and senior vice president.      

Poor CNN. It just can't buy a hoop.

On a huge story, the ratings-challenged cable news pioneer tossed up an airball.

"Mandate struck down," reported this morning. "High court finds measure unconstitutional."


"Supreme Court strikes down individual mandate portion of health care law," CNN tweeted.

Trouble was, the U.S. Supreme Court had just upheld President Barack Obama's landmark health care reform law.

Of course, CNN wasn't alone. Fox News Channel, the dominant force in cable news, also got it wrong. So, too, Politico reported, did a handful of tweet-happy congressmen.

It's easy to see why this happened. It was an enormously complicated story. Reporters were confronted with the daunting challenge of parsing four opinions totaling 187 pages in minutes.

And, in a sense, the court did strike down the mandate, which is how CNN got into trouble. Chief Justice John Roberts said in his ruling that the individual mandate to buy health care insurance didn't hold up under the Commerce Clause, as the Obama administration had argued. However, he went on to say that the legislation passed muster because the penalty for not buying health care insurance could be considered a tax, well within Congress' powers.

The tension between getting it first, or at least very, very fast, and getting it right has been around as long as journalism has. And it's on steroids in today's highly competitive media climate.

But it's always a good idea to know what you're talking about before you publish it, air it or tweet it. For example, at one point this morning, posted that its reporters and editors were poring over the opinions and would let the world know what they said as soon as they could figure it out. There's a concept.

AJR screenshot of CNN's original online report.

CNN said it best in its correction/apology for getting the story so wrong: "CNN regrets that it didn't wait to report out the full and complete opinion regarding the mandate." Reporting fully and completely is never a bad idea.

The timing couldn't be worse for CNN, whose ratings have been in freefall. In the second quarter of this year, the third-place cable news network suffered its lowest ratings since 1991. CNN invented the 24-hour news channel in 1980, and for years had the game to itself. Its mtier was news, straight down the middle news. But the world has changed dramatically in the intervening years.

Now it has two aggressive competitors in Fox and MSNBC. Fox established itself with a rightward tilt, MSNBC dragged itself out of its career-long doldrums by moving sharply left. And in today's hyperpolarized society, those partisan approaches have paid big dividends.

CNN has remained in the middle, which is admirable. But it seems tired. Its primetime lineup is particularly lackluster. And in the midst of a heated, high-interest presidential campaign, it has hardly established itself as the go-to place for political coverage. It seems desperately in need of a dynamic revival.

Its "Dewey Defeats Truman" moment on the health care ruling sure didn't help.




In the Astronomy rolex replica uk face, you can cycle assiduously or backwards in time, and watch angelic altar change their position. That accurate face aswell lets you accept whether you’re searching at the Earth (which will about-face already a day and appearance you what allotment of the Earth is in daylight) the Moon (ditto) or the positions of all the planets – just one of the abounding surprises rolex replica uk’s hidden in the Apple Watch. The ancillary button is added specific: a individual columnist will yield you to a card assuming your admired contacts, while a bifold columnist calls up Apple Pay; captivation it down brings up options to shut down, go into Ability Reserve approach (a low ability approach that shows alone the time) or lock the uk replica watches. I had no issues at all with array life, and usually begin myself with at atomic 20-30 percent array activity at the end of any accustomed day.