AJR  Columns :     TOP OF THE REVIEW    
From AJR,   November 1997

Roberts Will Direct Report on Newspapers   

Big takeouts will appear in AJR starting in the spring.

By Reese Cleghorn
Reese Cleghorn is former president of AJR and former dean of the College of Journalism of the University of Maryland.     


You will hear a lot about it before the first piece appears next spring: a series of thorough, reliable and highly readable reports on the state of the American newspaper that we believe will hold your attention through 200-plus pages of AJR.

Gene Roberts, now described as "the legendary newspaper editor" too often for his own good, will be editor-in-chief of the series. He has just finished three years as the managing editor of the New York Times and is returning to the full- time journalism faculty at the University of Maryland. (An earlier career: During the 18 years he was the top editor of the Philadelphia Inquirer, it won 17 Pulitzer Prizes.)

The talk about the series began even before it was announced. Will it bash newspaper companies? a few newspaper company executives were asking, certain the answer was yes because of Roberts' outspoken views on the perils of short-term thinking among some of the new breed in management. (Well, there will be surprises.)

Down in the newsroom there's a hum from a few who have heard. Will it really explain to people what worries me, what still turns me on about my work, and why I may want to get out or stay in forever? (We hope all of the above.)

If the series' findings were easy to predict, there should be no series. Already there has been plenty of articulation of angst, excitement, wonderment, hopefulness and gloom about where newspapers are heading. What we need now more than anything else is what our readers respect the most: first-class reporting that engages the best writers available, takes months of work, involves extensive travel and gets sufficient space in print.

The series will deal with the structures that produce the news – the companies and what makes them tick (and what makes some better than others) – as well as the news itself and how it is reported.

AJR will publish these reports beginning in a spring 1998 issue and continuing monthly.

The Project on the State of the American Newspaper is receiving $1 million for the first year. An advisory board headed by Roberts includes nationally known journalists Anna Quindlen, Norman Pearlstine, Charles Eisendrath and Beverly Kees.

The AJR series is an initiative of the Project for Excellence in Journalism, run by former Los Angeles Times media writer Tom Rosenstiel and headquartered in Washington, D.C., Rosenstiel's project receives money from the Pew Charitable Trusts and is affiliated with the Columbia Graduate School of Journalism. Rosenstiel also is launching other projects intended to analyze and improve practices in print and broadcast journalism.

The Project on the State of the American Newspaper is now in business at 8701-C Adelphi Road, Adelphi, Maryland, 20783. Tom Kunkel (tkunkel@ajr. umd.edu ), a respected newspaper editor and author, will be the series' editor, working with Roberts. The associate editor will be Carolyn White, veteran of the Philadelphia Inquirer and magazine editing.

Stay tuned.

###